Obviously I'm kind of late to this, but after Nightmare Nights I got sucked into Ponyfinder and haven't touched... well, any other board game for months. I busted out TSSSF last weekend, though, and decided to make a glorious comeback.
All that aside, I voted for Magical Mares just now. It was a hard decision for me between that and Rock Hard, but I decided there needs to be more anime in my shipping card game.